Talk:Girl (disambiguation)

removed dab entries

• Girl (Beck song), a song by Beck
• Girl (T. Rex song), a song by T. Rex
• Girl (short story), a short story by Jamaica Kincaid
• a number of films titled Girl:
  • Girl (1994 film) — a British made-for-television film directed by Peter Gill
  • Girl (1998 film) — a film starring Dominique Swain, Summer Phoenix, and Tara Reid
  • Girl (2001 film) — a German film directed by Piers Ashworth
  • Meisje ("Girl" in English) — a 2002 Dutch film directed by Dorothée Van Den Berghe

If any of these are noteable, please write the article and restore the entry. Until then, we don't have any reason to believe these articles will ever be written and they just junk up the page. Tedernst | talk 17:31, 20 December 2005 (UTC)

"Just" girls?

I believe things like Sky Girls as well as Moore's Lost Girls should be included. If we're going to be sticklers about it being 'just' girls then shouldn't Girls Inc. be removed because of the Inc actually being part of the title? Or that song 'Here Come the Girls', is there actually a source that this is referred to as just 'Girls'? If 3 words can just be dropped so casually I don't see why 1 can't. Tyciol (talk) 16:53, 17 May 2009 (UTC)

Good point: I have commented out the "Here Come the Girls" entry. If the alternate title is supported by an article, it can be restored. As for the Girls, Inc. entry, as I'm sure you know quite well, entities with Inc. in their names are often referred to by the Inc.-less version. And as for "Sky Girls", it is not an ambiguous usage and does not, therefore, need to be disambiguated from anything. For more information about the function and format of disambiguation pages, please consult WP:MOSDAB and WP:DAB. --ShelfSkewed Talk 21:19, 17 May 2009 (UTC)